![]() |
| Ich bin ein Englander, Frau Merkel! |
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Cameron's Folly
Saturday, January 12, 2013
Oh No, Not Again...
| Lord Moulton of Forgettery |
Wednesday, January 09, 2013
Twitter Trolls: Permanence, Insanity, Defamation and Forgetting
| Daniel Sickles, the first man acquitted by reason of temporary insanity in the US |
Monday, December 17, 2012
A Very French Slur
The French magazine Libération had a really nasty swipe at Gerard Depardieu during the week, after it was reported that he had decided to take up Belgian residency in order to avoid a French wealth tax. They accused M. Depardieu of being purely interested in money, an allegation that will have stung. It struck me that such an allegation would never have been made here in Ireland, because it would have no effect.
Thursday, December 13, 2012
The Problems with European Rugby
So talks have broken down again on the future of the European Cup in rugby. There appears to be deep mistrust between the parties, which is a shame. In essence, there are the English and French teams, who feel that the competition structure is biased in favour of the Irish teams in particular, and against them in general. This appears to be pretty much accurate. To compound that, the English feel that the preponderance of sponsorship is driven by their involvement, and their market - they're right on this also. At the very root of all of this, however, is a fundamental difference in philosophy as to how the game should be developed. And that, perhaps, is the most significant stumbling block of all.
Wednesday, December 12, 2012
Pat Finucane: Why Killing A Lawyer Matters
![]() |
| Pat Finucane, 1949-1989 |
Friday, November 09, 2012
The Unrelenting Consensus
![]() |
| Alexis de Tocqueville: I wonder what he would have made of Mattie McGrath? |
Thursday, November 08, 2012
Appreciating the Constitution
| The Government Site was replaced with a copy of the wording of the proposed amendment after the ruling. |
Wednesday, November 07, 2012
A Sensible Reason to Vote No to The Children Referendum
Apart from the drafting and interpretive issues with the Children's Rights amendment to the constitution, there are other practical issues. I'm not talking about John Waters and The Austerity Man coming to your door - but policy issues.
Thursday, November 01, 2012
Britain's Memory Problem
Euroscepticism in Britain has long been the foil of diplomatic strategists across the Irish Sea. Those charged with the navigation of grand strategy are conscious of Britain's place in the world, her diminishing military status, but relative cultural strength. Similarly, her proximity to Europe, and increasingly well integrated elites across the continent (and not just through royal marriage!) present an opportunity for Britain to be a bridge for both Americans who only speak English, and for the Chinese who have decided on English as their standard second language. In order to take advantage of that opportunity, Britain needs deeper ties to Europe, where she can exercise not insignificant clout, and even leadership, should she decide to.
Tuesday, October 30, 2012
Of Paper and Tablets
There are so many reasons why the procurement of tablets for TDs in order to save money on paper is a stupid, idiotic idea, I thought it would have been facetious to actually give it any thought. Then, on the News at One, Oireachtas head of Communications Mark Mulqueen comes on the radio and says that it will save money in the long term, as part of a move towards "the paperless office".
Monday, October 29, 2012
The Real European Economy
The austerity that is sweeping Europe is being broadly - if barely - accepted is being accepted because there is some sense that there have been excesses that need to be rectified. While there have concurrently been imbalances, and not all sectors of society have benefited, there is a socialised acceptance that some kind of redress needs to happen. In Germany, it was a little different. There has been sustained economic growth, budget surpluses, and general contentment; but it has been growth of a different kind from that of the post-war period. While in the post-war period the boom was based on reconstruction, this time Germany has generated wealth through prudent economics, but it has invested that wealth abroad.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
RTE and The Future of TV
Last night's love-in with RTE was a classic wolf in sheep's clothing. RTE decided to make a programme about television and its future, as part of the fiftieth anniversary programme, that was in effect an egregious, dishonest use of the license fee to defend the license fee itself. There was no real analysis of other markets and how they operate, because almost all of them operate differently to Ireland; some operate on a license fee without ads (Germany, France), while others operate on ads with no license fee (USA - though PBS is a specifically and exclusively federally funded organisation). RTE takes both, and screws up at both. For ad based content, you need to compete against other commercial channels - RTE's viewing figures have been steadily falling over the years. For license fee driven content, you need to advance the cultural and political objectives of the state: within the last twelve months, the monstrous treatment of Fr Kevin Reynolds, TweetGate and Sean Gallagher, were swiftly followed by the shutting of the London office of RTE.
Thursday, October 04, 2012
Positive Public Service
![]() |
| Romantic Ireland's Dead and Gone, It's with Whitaker in Retirement |
Monday, October 01, 2012
Monbiot and Python: Brothers in Arms
![]() |
| Scary corporate men coming to get you! |
― Alexis de Tocqueville
George Monbiot is a man of passion. He is one of the people who - in my mid twenties - helped me to see past the orthodoxy of western liberalism, and actually question the righteousness of the establishment. That was a good thing. But I moved on. As quickly as I understood that the establishment needed to be questioned, I understood the importance of perspective; that being outside the establishment made it difficult to see in, just as it was often painfully difficult for those within the establishment to see out.
Sunday, September 30, 2012
The GAA is an Anachronism
I've always loved Championship Sundays in the summer. It reminds me of days on the beach, with water too cold to swim in, cola flavoured Mr Freeze, and frenetic half-Irish commentary on the battery powered radio. These days, much older and far too wise for the folly of an Irish beach, I am afraid to say that the GAA has lost its relevance.
Monday, September 24, 2012
Tin Foil Hat: The State Monitoring Regime
As we meander our sorry way out of the mess of debt and poor tax policy, there are dozens of programmes underway to restructure the economy, and reset the expectations of a citizenry that chose not to be too critical while the gravy was flowing. The tax base is being broadened, services are being cut, excess is being eliminated, and the perpetual dance between the politicians and the mandarins continues at a pace that would have brought a wry smile to the face of Antony Jay, or of Jonathan Lynn.
Amongst the measures being introduced are the household charge / property tax, along with water metering. The ESB meanwhile is busy rolling out smart meters, which can do much more than simply measure energy consumption, they can broadcast energy readings back to base, obviating the need for meter readers (or notes from readers saying that they called but no one was in, when I was in). They can also, ultimately, get down to an appliance level and monitor and optimise consumption, theoretically allowing you to put on the kettle from a mile away, or turning on security lights from the other side of the world.
Amongst the measures being introduced are the household charge / property tax, along with water metering. The ESB meanwhile is busy rolling out smart meters, which can do much more than simply measure energy consumption, they can broadcast energy readings back to base, obviating the need for meter readers (or notes from readers saying that they called but no one was in, when I was in). They can also, ultimately, get down to an appliance level and monitor and optimise consumption, theoretically allowing you to put on the kettle from a mile away, or turning on security lights from the other side of the world.
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
Interpreting the Children's Rights Amendment
There are five key phrases that are likely to be open to wide-ranging interpretation in the proposed amendment to the Constitution, and likely to forum the nucleus of the upcoming debate:
1. "any of their children"
Clause 2 1° says in essence that the state can take over the role of the parents if they are bad parents. However, this is a point of vagueness in relation to the parents of multiple children. It could be interpreted that if a judgement is made that parents of multiple children are deemed bad to one of their children, then the state can legitimately supplant the parenting of all of the children. This is difficult in a conventional family, but in an unconventional family, for example where there are two or more fathers of children of one mother, it makes interpretation almost impossible. It should be changed to simply say "a child", rather than "any of their children".
2. "is likely to be prejudicially affected"
This represents a judgement that the extent to which parents are failing in their duties is objectively bad for the child in terms of either safety or welfare. A standard will need to be set for this judgement, in terms of welfare and safety but possibly other categories. For example, does "welfare" include education? If a child is a slow learner, who determines whether such lethargy is down to a failure in the duty of the parent?
3. "the place of the parents"
This one is a doozie. I can't imagine how an entire government can spend four or more years developing an amendment and leave this appallingly sloppy phrase in place. Leaving aside for a moment that this phrase all but codifies the phrase "Nanny State" in the constitution, is it the case that the state will adopt a legal obligation to correctly parent the child, and should that child not turn out so good, have the option to litigate? Only parents can parent. If the state seeks to care for a child, then they should enumerate the functions - food, shelter, education, healthcare. No more. The state will not teach a child right from wrong, or about the birds and the bees, nor should it have any obligation to, save in enforcing the law. The State is not and never will be a parent.
4. "the best interests of the child"
Again, who determines what are the best interests of the child? What are such standards? Is it in the best interests of the child that he be sent to a fee paying school? Or to Mosque on sabbath? Or to soccer training on Saturdays?
5. "any child who is capable of forming his or her own views"
This one is a nightmare. On the one hand, it needs to go in - you have to ask the child what they want, but then you also need to make a determination as to whether the child actually should have it. Children may ask for sweets for breakfast, lunch and dinner, but it's not good for them. But that is certainly a view, and the child will have been well capable of articulating it, even demanding it. This phrase really boils down to the definition of a child. Is it someone under eighteen? There are boys with AK47s in the jungles of Congo as young as 10. So putting in an age would have been difficult too.
All in all, this reads more like a policy paper than a constitutional amendment. My view? They should have been more brief and less prescriptive. That's what constitutions are about. This is too long winded, and dives into too much detail and tries to do too much. It will fail, because any one of the five items above, interpreted in a particular way, has the potential to upset everyone.
1. "any of their children"
Clause 2 1° says in essence that the state can take over the role of the parents if they are bad parents. However, this is a point of vagueness in relation to the parents of multiple children. It could be interpreted that if a judgement is made that parents of multiple children are deemed bad to one of their children, then the state can legitimately supplant the parenting of all of the children. This is difficult in a conventional family, but in an unconventional family, for example where there are two or more fathers of children of one mother, it makes interpretation almost impossible. It should be changed to simply say "a child", rather than "any of their children".
2. "is likely to be prejudicially affected"
This represents a judgement that the extent to which parents are failing in their duties is objectively bad for the child in terms of either safety or welfare. A standard will need to be set for this judgement, in terms of welfare and safety but possibly other categories. For example, does "welfare" include education? If a child is a slow learner, who determines whether such lethargy is down to a failure in the duty of the parent?
3. "the place of the parents"
This one is a doozie. I can't imagine how an entire government can spend four or more years developing an amendment and leave this appallingly sloppy phrase in place. Leaving aside for a moment that this phrase all but codifies the phrase "Nanny State" in the constitution, is it the case that the state will adopt a legal obligation to correctly parent the child, and should that child not turn out so good, have the option to litigate? Only parents can parent. If the state seeks to care for a child, then they should enumerate the functions - food, shelter, education, healthcare. No more. The state will not teach a child right from wrong, or about the birds and the bees, nor should it have any obligation to, save in enforcing the law. The State is not and never will be a parent.
4. "the best interests of the child"
Again, who determines what are the best interests of the child? What are such standards? Is it in the best interests of the child that he be sent to a fee paying school? Or to Mosque on sabbath? Or to soccer training on Saturdays?
5. "any child who is capable of forming his or her own views"
This one is a nightmare. On the one hand, it needs to go in - you have to ask the child what they want, but then you also need to make a determination as to whether the child actually should have it. Children may ask for sweets for breakfast, lunch and dinner, but it's not good for them. But that is certainly a view, and the child will have been well capable of articulating it, even demanding it. This phrase really boils down to the definition of a child. Is it someone under eighteen? There are boys with AK47s in the jungles of Congo as young as 10. So putting in an age would have been difficult too.
All in all, this reads more like a policy paper than a constitutional amendment. My view? They should have been more brief and less prescriptive. That's what constitutions are about. This is too long winded, and dives into too much detail and tries to do too much. It will fail, because any one of the five items above, interpreted in a particular way, has the potential to upset everyone.
Monday, August 27, 2012
Patent Law versus Anti-Trust
I've thought for some time that intellectual property law generally was in trouble, and as an artificial construct that requires positive law to support it, the lack of universal application certainly gives cause for concern. In essence, the Internet allows the publication of all intellectual property, instantly, to almost everyone in the world.
Ownership of intellectual property is intangible; ideas, inventions, innovations are nebulous concepts, and to award the official title of ownership to the first person or company who has either the wit or resources to go through the registration process first (or, as kids would say, "baggsies!!") seems arbitrary. We are social beings, and operate within a social construct. If you invent something, say, in the shower, should the shower owner own a piece of it? If your thought process is triggered by a movie, should the studio claim a piece?
Ownership of intellectual property is intangible; ideas, inventions, innovations are nebulous concepts, and to award the official title of ownership to the first person or company who has either the wit or resources to go through the registration process first (or, as kids would say, "baggsies!!") seems arbitrary. We are social beings, and operate within a social construct. If you invent something, say, in the shower, should the shower owner own a piece of it? If your thought process is triggered by a movie, should the studio claim a piece?
Sunday, August 26, 2012
Lance Armstrong: A Metaphor for Modern Sport
![]() |
| What? Something on my nose? |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















